Quellenangaben und historische Zitate bleiben erhalten. Redaktionelle Hinweise stehen beim jeweiligen Abschnitt.
1. For the published version of this thesis, see Goll (2009).
2. Ffoulkes (1912).
3. Price et al. (2000).
4. Most of the results are presented together in Williams (2003).
5. For example, Thomas and Gamber (1976), pp. 25–34.
6. In this study, an arsenal is a facility storing military equipment for large numbers of soldiers. Its stock could be issued rapidly to personnel or citizens in times of danger or war.
7. Objects are counted separately by the body area protected. Thus an articulated arm defence comprising upper-arm, elbow and forearm plates counts as three objects, while an isolated visor counts as one helmet record. I examined and photographed about 1,300 of these objects at high resolution.
8. See for example: Anonymous (1930), pl. 2.
9. Gamber et al. (1972-1996).
10. Boccia and Coelho (1967); Boccia (1982).
11. Rossi (1972); Thomas (1977a).
12. Boeheim (1889); Thomas and Gamber (1977).
13. Thomas (1944); Reitzenstein (1942).
14. Tiroler Landesmuseum Ferdinandeum (1954); Thomas (1974); Egg (1992).
15. Boeheim (1895); Reitzenstein (1967); Thomas (1977c); Willers (1978).
16. Frauenhofer (2004); Kalcher (1895); Spitzlberger (1975); Spitzlberger (1985).
17. Boeheim (1891); Boeheim (1892); Boeheim (1893); Buff (1893); Reitzenstein (1955).
18. Ffoulkes (1912), p. 136-137; Thomas and Gamber (1976), p. 195.
19. Terjanian (2009).
20. Calvert (1907); Mann (1933).
21. Grancsay (1929); Williams and Reuck (1995).
22. In the late Middle Ages and early Renaissance, “Rüstung” could denote a type of crossbow; see Sensfelder (2009). It also referred to winches, probably explaining its use for crossbows spanned by a winch. Its later application to armour remains unclear. I thank Jens Sensfelder for this information.
23. Terjanian (2001) p. 158.
24. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1895), Reg. 12675.
25. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1895), Reg. 13542.
26. See also the various essays (e. g. Janitz, Schuppert, Wilckens) on the problem of medieval terminology and typology in: Appelt (1988).
27. For the English translation the author of this paper has chosen the terms commonly used in English literature.
28. Transcribed from: Statthaltereiarchiv Innsbruck, Miscellanea 92 by: Schönherr (1900), p.79-680.
29. The Limburger Chronik uses “hundeskogeln” in 1389 in a context also listing breastplates and leg armour. This supports interpreting the word as a helmet, without establishing that every wearer had a complete ensemble. The passage apparently includes citizens and infantry as well as knights; see Post (1936), p. 179.
30. See for example: Schönherr (1900), p.79-680.
31. Inventories record two “tschelern” or “tschaelaern” in 1425 and three “tscheleden” in 1426; see Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1899), Reg. 17568 and 17573. Their German pronunciation resembles Italian “celata” more closely than “Schale” (bowl), often proposed as the German term’s root.
32. Blair cites sixteenth-century French, English and Spanish sources using the term for an open-faced helmet with a forehead peak and short flared nape guard: Blair (1972), p. 136.
33. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1900), Reg. 18319.
34. Ffoulkes (1911), p. 383.
35. Müller-Hickler (1932-34), p. 179.
36. To keep references concise, individual objects are identified below by their record IDs.
37. The source identifies no neck defence made from small plates secured to a textile or leather covering.
38. See e. g.: Statthaltereiarchiv Innsbruck, Miscellanea 92, edited in: Schönherr (1900), p.79-680.
39. See e. g.: Statthaltereiarchiv Innsbruck, Miscellanea 92, edited in: Schönherr (1900), p.79-680.
40. Compare also the arm defenses acc. no. A79 in the HJRK.
41. Type II is omitted because no examples survive in the classification. Type III retains its number for the fully enclosing form, by analogy with lower-leg protection.
42. Both “helmet” and “head defence” or “head protection” are used below, following common English usage.
43. For illustrative explanations on the development of all medieval helmet types see the chart in: Nickel (1974), p. 118.
44. Ffoulkes (1911), p. 383.
45. This is also the historical term, see: Strauch (1986), p.185.
46. Post (1936), p. 179.
47. For a comprehensive discussion on the development of this helmet-type see: Trapp (1926).
48. An exception is [ref_arm_4487] PDF, whose missing face guard was probably attached by staple and pin; see also Trapp (1926), p. 28.
49. The narrowing skull and rounded, flared nape guard place this helmet in Type V. Studies extending beyond 1500 may require a further category for “closed helmets”, perhaps Type IX.
50. See Henry VIII.’s foot-combat armour acc. no. II.6 in the RA.
51. See Henry VIII.’s foot-combat armour acc. no. II.6 in the RA.
52. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1883), Reg. 48.
53. This offline version of the database contains many objects beyond those cited in the text, allowing readers to make further comparisons.
54. Boeheim (2000), of course old, but still very useful for a general overview.
55. Gamber (1953) and Gamber (1955).
56. Blair (1972).
57. “Iron” and “steel” require care. Modern terminology includes forgeable iron alloys with up to about 2% carbon under steel, distinguishing higher-carbon cast iron; see Bargel (2012), p. 141. Historic usage commonly distinguished hardenable steel from softer iron. The source uses about 0.4% carbon as an approximate threshold, although hardenability is not governed by one universal boundary. Material quality cannot be established confidently without examination. Some armour is hardened or hardenable; other objects use softer iron. Earlier humanities scholarship sometimes applies these terms without testing or considering historic usage. This study therefore uses “iron or steel” where quality is unknown, and the terms separately when a particular material quality is intended.
58. This is for the arm: shoulder, upper arm, elbow and lower arm; for the leg: upper leg, knee, lower leg and foot.
59. This is different possible wearing-combinations of torso front and -back types.
60. Between about 1270 and 1350, chiefly in France, small shoulder-mounted shields known as “ailettes” or “Achselschilde” appear [ref_ill_art_5189] PDF. Their purpose is uncertain and a protective role disputed; see Nickel (2002). They are therefore excluded from the defensive classification here.
61. For reconstruction of leather hardening and a historical survey of leather armour, see Beabey and Richardson (1997).
62. See Burkhard von Seckendorf’s effigy (d. 1365), Heilig Geist Kirche, Gunzenhausen. I thank Christopher Retsch for this reference.
63. Blair (1972).
64. For details see chapter [Turning via sliding rivets [ref_ill_joi_turningviaslidingrivets]].
65. Cosson (1884), Mann (1942), Goll (2009).
66. For a discussion of several segmented hand-protections found in Wisby see: Thordeman (1940).
67. All organic components are lost, so the original arrangement of the finger plates remains uncertain.
68. This finger type is most likely genuine due to the old provenance of all quoted items.
69. The fingers are entirely reproductions.
70. Blair (1972), p. 47.
71. The supposed sight slit is too high to function. It may instead be damage from a sword or staff weapon.
72. The British and the Canadian army used a steel-helmet of type-III (MKI and MKII) from 1915 to 1945.
73. A second one is attached to the type-I helmet [ref_arm_2093] PDF.
74. The visor and the collar are lost.
75. Trapp (1926).
76. Blair (1972), p. 39.
77. The shell-like extension also permits a less likely interpretation as a late fourteenth-century Type II elbow defence with upper-arm protection. If so, it would be the only example with a medial elbow ridge.
78. Blair (1972), p. 39.
79. The painted figure wears metal strips on the outside of the lower legs, resembling arm-defence “jack chains”.
80. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1883), Reg. 48.
81. Blair (1972), p. 37.
82. It is possible that the badly damaged item [ref_arm_5127] PDF also was similarly box-shaped.
83. I found the upper-leg lames detached in a box; an older image shows them attached [ref_ill_art_5396] PDF. Another photograph [ref_ill_art_5395] PDF records comparable plates now missing from breastplate [ref_arm_3668] PDF. At the time of this study, they were thought likely to remain among recently relocated museum holdings awaiting unpacking.
84. Dean (1921), p. 60.
85. A relatively recent example is the use of black-and-white illustrations in Eaves (2002).
86. Other developments have also helped, including the relatively low cost of travel at the time of writing.
87. On authenticity, see Chapter 6, “The problem of authenticity”.
88. The bars around the arm openings are missing. Their former presence is indicated by holes, now occupied by rivets, that otherwise have no function.
89. For a discussion of the interrelationship between contemporary costume and armour see for example: Grancsay (1931) and Grancsay (1950).
90. Thomas (1977b), p. 626.
91. See discussion below in chapter [New recognitions on marks] and [A suit in the BMA].
92. Hammer scale is iron oxide formed on iron or steel heated to red heat or above in air. The source gives the reaction 3 Fe + 2 O₂ → Fe₃O₄.
93. See: Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1896), Reg. 15325. Translation by the author: […] two iron-hats, black and white […] but with the exception the best iron-hat for my wife […], it should stay for my housewife in the house […].
94. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1884), Reg. 1010: „[…] unz zum hertnen und ausfeilen 12 Krebsen […]“. Translation by the author: […] until the hardening and the filing 12 breastplates […].
95. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1900), Reg. 18749.
96. See: Thomas and Gamber (1976), p. 27.
97. Thomas and Gamber (1976), p. 104, pl. 32-33.
98. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1899), Reg. 17646. Translation by the author: […] 19 ducaten to the armourer; the silver on the plates cost five markh; and three gulden from one mark cost the gilding; and two gulden of the mark as salary […].
99. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1899), Reg. 17774. Translation by the author: For the gilding of the armour for Scotland I have paid 10 ducaten and 4 r. gulden in the presence of the goldsmith Fuchs Micheln.
100. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1899), Reg. 17896. Translation by the author, retained from the dissertation: “1465 Juli 10. On behalf of my Lord I have given 6 ducaten to the Hofmeister Hainrichen von Freyberg to have gilded the armour of the young emperor.”
101. The irregular lines on suit [ref_arm_4143] PDF, to which this neck defence belongs, may be etched. If so, they would represent an early example of armour etching.
102. Kastner et al. (2007).
103. Museen der Stadt Landshut (2009) illustrates several helmets with rivet rows along the edges; figures 33 and 63 include sixth-century BC examples.
104. See for example the 1544 billing of expenses of Henry VIII.’s Royal Armouries in: Ffoulkes (1912), p. 183.
105. Seventeenth-century arsenal inventories and bills use “Krebs-Nögl” and “Harnisch Nögel”: Wettendorfer (1943–44), p. 75. The court armourer Konrad Seusenhofer likewise refers to “nagl” in 1511: Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1884), Reg. 1028. A document of 1499 suggests that the term already denoted rivets in the fifteenth century. Maximilian I permits the transport of “eysen, stachl [steel] vnnd allerlay nagl” to Innsbruck for his needs: Böhmer and Wiesflecker (1990–1996), Reg. 13436 (http://regesten.regesta-imperii.de/index.php?uri=1499-06-19_4_0_14_3_2_640_13436). These supplies most probably served the armour workshops at Mühlau near Innsbruck; on this interpretation, the nails were rivets for attaching fittings.
106. Knee defences [ref_arm_2678] PDF [ref_arm_2846] PDF are exceptions: their sliding plate joints use Type a rivets. The legs have been extensively repaired, so these rivets may be replacements. The upper thigh lames use Type b rivets, as usual for those joints.
107. Pyhrr (2006), here p. 109-111.
108. Scalini (1996), p. 67 (German text).
109. Rossi and Di Carpegna also observed the similar helmet rivets and proposed a modern date: Rossi and Di Carpegna (1969), p. 39.
110. Wackernagel (1982a), p. 25, f).
111. Wackernagel collaborated with Mario Scalini on the Munich Zeughaus catalogue and probably obtained this suggestion from him. Scalini says that the “a bozzetta” rivets of the Munich breastplates “are not very different from certain original rivets on parts of armour that is certainly Italian and from more or less the same date.” As a comparable example for an Italian breastplate with a similar rivet he names an example from the Santuario della Madonna delle Grazie di Curtatone near Mantua. It is not clear where this item is stored now and no image is included in Scalini’s catalogue. Nevertheless, he is more careful than Wackernagel in drawing conclusions on a close relationship between the Churburg’s Brescian breastplates and those in Munich when he quotes: “This fact [the Italian-style rivets] unfortunately, cannot be considered to have probative force on the Munich breastplates being of Brescian origin since the sources, especially the Datini archive of Prato, speak of a massive trade in these tiny products, which were evidently put on the market by Lombard workshops at extremely competitive prices, if it was thought worthwhile to transport rivets to Avignon. Tuscany and elsewhere. Apart from possible later interventions, intended to improve pieces for museum purposes, one has to note how these rivets appear also on German pieces, and that there are notable differences between the Churburg and the Munich breastplates.”, for all quotes see: Scalini (1996), p. 71. I could find no breastplate outside the Munich group with a similarly decorated central rivet.
112. Wackernagel (1982a), p. 115.
113. Pyhrr (2000), p. 9, cat. no. 7.
114. [ref_arm_1900] PDF [ref_arm_1773] PDF [ref_arm_1742] PDF [ref_arm_1660] PDF [ref_arm_1686] PDF [ref_arm_1701] PDF [ref_arm_1707] PDF [ref_arm_1725] PDF [ref_arm_1797] PDF [ref_arm_1821] PDF [ref_arm_1826] PDF [ref_arm_1832] PDF [ref_arm_1837] PDF [ref_arm_1857] PDF [ref_arm_1865] PDF [ref_arm_1898] PDF [ref_arm_1899] PDF [ref_arm_4290] PDF [ref_arm_4397] PDF.
115. See discussion below in chapter [New recognitions on marks] and [A suit in the BMA].
116. Ffoulkes (1912), here p.183.
117. This is particularly surprising given the nineteenth-century demand for rivets in boilers, metal-framed buildings and ships.
118. See: Anonymus (1828).
119. Lueger (1908), here p.570-571. Translated by the author.
120. I experimented with making such rivets; see Goll (2009), pp. 02–103 [page range as printed; to be checked]. That method was rather cumbersome because I was not yet aware of the etching technique.
121. “Old” does not necessarily mean original to the object: a rivet may be a much later replacement made by traditional methods.
122. In the axonometric view of [ref_arm_1075] PDF, a loose rivet on the right exposes its shank and diameter. Note also the varying head diameters.
123. The restorer Ian Ashdown in Onnens (CH) uses such rivets.
124. Starley (2006), p. 4.
125. Starley gives copper-to-zinc ratios of 8:3 for modern brass and 7:3 for material predating a new zinc-production method introduced in 1743: Starley (2006), pp. 3–5. These are source-specific comparisons, not universal compositions for all brass.
126. The copper-alloy examples on [ref_arm_1398] PDF [ref_arm_1692] PDF may be solid castings; closer examination was not possible.
127. Again with the exception of [ref_arm_1398] PDF and [ref_arm_1692] PDF.
128. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1884), Reg. 1028, also indicates that inexpensive infantry buckles were purchased rather than made by the armourers. For the obsolete terms “rincken” or “rinken”, see http://www.woerterbuchnetz.de/DWB?lemma=rinke (16 March 2012).
129. Dean (1921) gives little provenance information for his illustrated buckles. Since similar forms served civilian clothing and sword belts, an isolated buckle cannot securely be assigned to armour.
130. Fingerlin traces roller buckles to the mid-thirteenth century, although the earlier forms differ from those on plate armour: Fingerlin (1971), pp. 70–74.
131. The buckle on [ref_arm_4904] PDF is probably late fifteenth-century or later, but its attachment is not original. The crude mounting plate contrasts with the finely made hand defence and partly covers an unused hole. That hole may have held an internal strap or the hinge of a now-lost wrist flap. See Goll (2009), p. 36. The source’s phrase “or early century” lacks a century number.
132. No visible gilding was identified during this study. Chemical examination of buckles may provide further evidence.
133. The buckle references below are selected examples, not an exhaustive list. Further comparisons could include all recorded objects with potentially original buckles.
134. The buckle on [ref_arm_810] PDF may have lost its roller. Although the buckles appear old, their relationship to the armour’s manufacture is uncertain. Different mounting plates on either side indicate reattachment.
135. Ffoulkes (1912), p.78.
136. Berger (2006), p.5, plate A-48.
137. For difficulties in identifying the original use of excavated buckles, see Fingerlin (1971), pp. 12–13; for armour, pp. 186–187.
138. Detailed examination of this suit was not possible. Further access to its buckles and other small fittings would be valuable.
139. Thomas and Gamber classify all straps and buckles as modern: Thomas and Gamber (1976), p. 106. Nevertheless, the rounded single-frame buckle with a decorated mounting plate on elbow defence [ref_arm_533] PDF could be contemporary with the suit.
140. See Thomas and Gamber (1976), pl. 40. The displayed hand defences were subsequently replaced with [ref_arm_1059] PDF [ref_arm_1124] PDF.
141. Copies of Vienna armour buckles were made before 1921, but Dean does not identify the originals concerned: Dean (1921), p. 62.
142. See for example the hydra-crest A2126 of the HJRK.
143. Trapp (1995), p. 55.
144. Brooker (2007), p. 325, together with the wheel lock gun RG73.
145. Capwell (2002).
146. See chapter [Front].
147. Treitzsaurwein (1775), p. 97-98. Translation of the author: Once upon a time the young wise king [Maximillian I.] rode into a fierce fighting and as he put on all his armour and his fencing-armour, his armoury-master wanted to close his main-armour tightly with screws, so no one would open it by a strike. In this moment, the king asked his armoury-master what would be better: If someone had the control in his own hands or if someone else had the control. The master answered: The one who is in control, is the ruler. So the king said: That is why I want to be in control of the armour and I do not want to depend on you if I have to open my armour. I know that you want to do this for my own well, but you do not know that from your unconsidered or unconscious good will a lot of misery might emerge. By this, everyone might understand that this king was a teacher to other kings in concerns of arms and armour.
148. Plates [ref_arm_3437] PDF [ref_arm_3434] PDF may once have been detachable. Unused central internal slots could have served a bolt-and-eye or hook-and-eye connection.
149. Early sixteenth-century images sometimes show breastplates apparently worn without pelvis protection [ref_ill_art_5381] PDF. Type III predominated in German-speaking regions, but I know no surviving contemporary example with a detachable thoracic-to-abdominal joint; the known plates are permanently riveted.
150. The breastplate seen in this video was made by Peter Müller in 2012 after the extant example [ref_arm_3624] PDF.
151. Some Italian front- and backplates have to be put on together as they are connected via hinges.
152. In the Italian system, lateral hinges and buckles secure the torso plates without fastening the centre of the abdominal plate. Buckles at its upper points therefore need not necessarily have been used.
153. Tobias Capwell incorporated this construction into a reproduced suit, probably following Richard de Beauchamp’s effigy [ref_ill_art_5233] PDF (description 1). No corresponding breastplate survives, and the apparent waist gap may instead be a seam between parts of the cast monument.
154. Some Type I shoulder defences may have buckled to the upper arm. Paired holes also permit an original laced attachment at the lower edge [ref_arm_329] PDF.
155. The detachable components of German-system arm defences make the original arrangement difficult to establish. Surviving laced arrangements are modern; their holes may formerly have held rivets [ref_arm_254] PDF.
156. Exceptions include [ref_arm_1060] PDF [ref_arm_1209] PDF and their counterparts. The cuffs associated with [ref_arm_1209] PDF may have been interchanged during restoration. The objects are visibly altered and the flap hinges are missing.
157. Horse-head-protections were usually also padded.
158. At the left counterpart [ref_arm_2370] PDF the leather straps are modern replacements.
159. Thomas and Gamber (1976), p. 182.
160. A tin coating visible when I photographed the breastplate in 2007 had disappeared by February 2011. The washer is copper alloy; tin could have limited copper corrosion from perspiration and consequent damage to the lining.
161. The holes are now closed with rivets. The breastplate may combine two later Type II plates: comparable holes occur on simple infantry examples [ref_arm_3498] PDF, but not on similarly elaborate objects. Its ridge pattern resembles a backplate, especially where ridges cross from the abdominal to the thoracic plate; compare the associated [ref_arm_3264] PDF, which lacks the small holes. A lining or outer cover would impede the articulated joint. Yet a reconstruction from Type II breastplates also leaves unexplained the absence of waist cut-outs common around 1500.
162. This is especially plausible for [ref_arm_2093] PDF, probably made before 1350, which lacks forehead lining holes. A skull cap still required retention, perhaps straps at the lower edge above the ears or lacing to a padded cap secured under the chin.
163. Maintaining the collection was a Trapp family tradition: Scalini (1996), p. 17 (German edition).
164. Trapp (1995), p.22-23.
165. Both helmets also have permanent linings, making the purpose of the paired holes uncertain.
166. This is a small heraldic blanket in between the helmet and the crest.
167. In these holes also metal wedges similar to those on e. g. [ref_arm_2121] PDF might have been fixed.
168. Trapp (1995), p. 29.
169. For [ref_arm_3059] PDF see: Trapp (1995), p. 73.
170. A London regulation of 1322 prohibited textile-covered helmets so that workmanship remained visible: Ffoulkes (1912), pp. 169–170.
171. A handover inventory of 1436 from Wiener-Neustadt lists numerous armour objects, including: “…item 15 gancz eisnein [i. e. iron] platten; item ain roten samadtein [i. e. velvet] platten und ain rot samadtein helmlin”. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1883), Reg. 48.
172. For the interpretation of the inscription see: Grönwald (2010), p. 187.
173. Part of the copper-alloy cuff band on the wrist’s inner side was replaced, possibly during use. The replacement is redder, lacks engraving and only crudely imitates the original embossing.
174. The roped copper-alloy wrist ring is missing from this right-hand defence but can be reconstructed from its left counterpart [ref_arm_1278] PDF.
175. Only two small detached segments survive, for the interpretation of the inscription see: Grönwald (2010), p. 187.
176. These objects were not examined directly, so the interpretation is tentative. Excavated with other armour at Cēsis Castle, the separately displayed forearm components [ref_arm_117] PDF probably belong together, judging by hinges, corresponding holes and decorative bands. They may form an associated arm defence with shoulder [ref_arm_879] PDF; shared decoration and find context support that possibility.
177. Depictions show that applied decoration continued on Italian armour after 1460. Verrocchio’s Colleoni monument of 1496 in Venice has relief-decorated bands along many edges. Titian’s helmet [ref_ill_art_5397] PDF has a gilded engraved crest and apparently copper-alloy edges and rivet heads. A closely related helmet [ref_ill_art_5221] PDF differs chiefly in its black surface and visor. An effigy of about 1441, apparently representing an English adaptation of Italian armour, also has decorative bands [ref_ill_art_5265] PDF.
178. Well-known examples with gilded or silvered fittings include Henry VIII’s ensemble, RA II.5, c. 1514, and that of Archduke Karl, later Emperor Karl V, HJRK A109, c. 1514. The dissertation describes both as “Faltenrockharnisch” ensembles made in Augsburg by Konrad Seusenhofer. A further example is the “Blau-goldener Küriß”, HJRK A578, c. 1557, by an anonymous maker, probably in Augsburg. The place attribution and its relationship to the chronology in §4.2.6.3.2 require author review.
179. Lost-wax casting is proposed. Filing the bands from solid stock is possible, but their symmetrical relief makes casting more likely.
180. See discussion below in chapter [New recognitions on marks] and [A suit in the BMA].
181. Mann (1962), p. 13-14.
182. Mann (1962), p. 11 and Edge and Williams (2001), p. 235.
183. Dean (1925), p. 134.
184. Thomas and Gamber (1976), p. 97. Examination of the lower edge could establish whether the present bands replaced earlier fittings or conceal a formerly turned edge.
185. Thomas and Gamber (1976), p. 10. The restorations may date between plans for public display around 1863 and installation in 1889.
186. Tracery is occasionally also found at contemporary arms, like crossbow-winches (in Engl. Literature called “cranequins”) or sword-pommels.
187. Roping on the lowest lames of other Helmschmied objects [ref_arm_3294] PDF [ref_arm_3695] PDF was also flattened. The latter backplate gained another pelvis lame; the inside of the second-lowest still preserves its former roped lower border.
188. See: Goll (2009), p. 46.
189. Thomas and Gamber (1976), p.100.
190. Thomas and Gamber (1976), p. 114-115.
191. A goldsmith or “Rotgießer” specialising in copper-alloy casting probably made these complex fittings. Comparable fifteenth-century goldsmiths’ work includes Sigismund’s drinking horn (Esztergom, Föszékedegyházi Kincstár, acc. no. 1964.18.1,2), whose fleur-de-lys bands resemble the Helmschmied fittings: Takács (2006), pp. 370–371.
192. See discussion below in chapter [New recognitions on marks] and [A suit in the BMA].
193. Fragments of copper-alloy rivets remain in some holes along the right shoulder’s lower edge.
194. I did not handle this breastplate. Gamber (1957), p. 40, states that its lowest lame had applied decoration, removed and flattened when upper-leg plates were added around 1490.
195. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1899), Reg. 18210, calls Maximilian “the young Emperor”. “Thoma” is probably the court armourer of Archduke Sigismund mentioned in Reg. 17972 of the same volume.
196. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1900), Reg. 19193.
197. The crane-mounting myth appears in Olivier’s 1944 film “Henry V”: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=3jXFnQUU7yg (10 August 2012). Germany’s “Sendung mit der Maus” repeated it in 1985: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=-y4j4QhU2nI (10 August 2012). Dirk Breiding of the MET later challenged it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NqC_squo6X4&feature=player_detailpage (10 August 2012).
198. See chapter [Systems] and [Systems].
199. Blair (1972), p. 189.
200. Repeated polishing has removed some material, but losses of a few tenths of a millimetre are not considered sufficient to alter the broad comparisons here.
201. Too little comparable Type VIII data was available; its examination remains a task for future research.
202. Measurements concern the skull at the edge of its reinforcing overlap. Rear measurements come from the narrow integral tail between Type VI cheek plates; upper frontal measurements concern the face guard.
203. For comparisons of type-I breastplates not enough data was at hand.
204. The measurements of the pelvis-lames were omitted, as many important comparable items lacked these lames.
205. Because Type III abdominal plates are narrow and the thoracic plate covers much of the abdomen, an additional section was measured on the latter.
206. Insufficient data excluded Type I and II backplates from the thickness comparison.
207. No type-III neck-protections could be measured.
208. “Mass production” may overstate medieval or Renaissance standardisation. Even where many examples of a model were made, substantial hand-finishing left differences between individual products.
209. See for example the discussion of the helmet [ref_arm_1710] PDF in chapter [Helmets].
210. Egg (1992).
211. Numerous objects entering the antiquities market during the past two centuries also came from these arsenals.
212. Williams (2003), p. 889.
213. Gardner (1898), p. 14.
214. Karcheski and Richardson assembled extensive evidence on the Rhodes armour: Karcheski and Richardson (2003).
215. Pyhrr (1989).
216. Ffoulkes (1911), pp. 381–382. Hefner-Alteneck (1854), p. 83, pl. 63, places the discovery in the castle cistern and includes imprecise drawings of several helmets.
217. Euboea and Chalcis became part of the newly established Greek state in 1830. Had Ottoman authorities found the armour earlier, it might have been transferred to Istanbul.
218. Buchon (1843), p. 134.
219. Blair (1983); Ffoulkes (1911) and V assilatos (1934).
220. Scalini (1984), p. 3-5.
221. Norman (not dated) and Boccia (not dated).
222. All these texts study the helmets, but not the limb protections stored in the MET, mentioned below.
223. Bashford Dean, MET arms and armour curator from 1906 to 1928, acquired these objects for his private collection around 1920. The MET purchased them after his death in 1928; see Grancsay and Kienbusch (1933). Identifying every Chalcis object requires further research because pieces were supplemented or combined with other originals. Dean (1925) discusses suit [ref_arm_3236] PDF, assembled chiefly from Chalcis material.
224. These are: [ref_arm_1462] PDF [ref_arm_1984] PDF [ref_arm_1988] PDF [ref_arm_1989] PDF [ref_arm_1990] PDF [ref_arm_1991] PDF [ref_arm_1992] PDF [ref_arm_2011] PDF [ref_arm_2022] PDF [ref_arm_2059] PDF [ref_arm_2063] PDF [ref_arm_2072] PDF [ref_arm_2103] PDF [ref_arm_2127] PDF [ref_arm_2144] PDF [ref_arm_2146] PDF (lower plate only) [ref_arm_2167] PDF [ref_arm_4389] PDF [ref_arm_4584] PDF [ref_arm_4617] PDF [ref_arm_5112] PDF.
225. Three helmets elsewhere are attributed to Chalcis: [ref_arm_4389] PDF [ref_arm_4617] PDF [ref_arm_2059] PDF. Another, [ref_arm_2072] PDF, remained for centuries in an Ottoman arsenal. Thousands of objects reached Europe from those stores in 1839–1840: Pyhrr (1989), p. 87. Comparable helmets remained in Istanbul, as Dean’s photographs reproduced by Pyhrr show, so some supposed Chalcis examples may instead come from there. Detached lower plate [ref_arm_2146] PDF could belong to a surviving skull; the source proposes a revised total of eighteen, although the count requires clarification. Lower plates on [ref_arm_4617] PDF [ref_arm_2103] PDF [ref_arm_2059] PDF are modern replacements.
226. The detached MET visors probably came from Chalcis through Dean. Their associated skulls may still survive in Athens.
227. Not all items are from Chalcis, but due to their similarity they belong to this group: [ref_arm_1445] PDF [ref_arm_1446] PDF [ref_arm_1447] PDF [ref_arm_1448] PDF [ref_arm_1449] PDF [ref_arm_1450] PDF [ref_arm_1451] PDF [ref_arm_1452] PDF [ref_arm_1453] PDF [ref_arm_1454] PDF [ref_arm_1455] PDF [ref_arm_1458] PDF [ref_arm_1473] PDF [ref_arm_1474] PDF [ref_arm_1475] PDF [ref_arm_1476] PDF [ref_arm_1477] PDF [ref_arm_1478] PDF [ref_arm_1479] PDF [ref_arm_1480] PDF [ref_arm_1483] PDF [ref_arm_1487] PDF [ref_arm_1588] PDF [ref_arm_1590] PDF [ref_arm_2147] PDF [ref_arm_4408] PDF [ref_arm_4460] PDF.
228. At least one is a converted or re-used older helmet [ref_arm_1453] PDF.
229. Published dates vary widely: early fourteenth century for Type V and late fourteenth for Type II (Vassilatos, pp. 123–133, 136); 1430s–1460s (Boccia, p. 7); 1370–1390 (Scalini, p. 4); broadly mid-fourteenth century to 1470 (Ffoulkes); and about 1310 (Buchon), considered too early here.
230. Martin (1967), p. 60 and Reverseau (1982), p. 22.
231. Giorgio Bini reportedly found [ref_arm_5112] PDF in the Tiber: Blair (1983), p. 14, note 14.
232. Boccia (undated), pp. 10–11, sees eastern and Byzantine influences, particularly in the pointed skulls.
233. Other comparable helmets either lack reliable provenance or are attributed to Chalcis. None can therefore be securely associated with use in the western Mediterranean or central Europe.
234. These are: [ref_arm_1981] PDF [ref_arm_1986] PDF [ref_arm_1993] PDF [ref_arm_2000] PDF [ref_arm_2051] PDF [ref_arm_2073] PDF [ref_arm_2095] PDF [ref_arm_2097] PDF [ref_arm_2098] PDF [ref_arm_2112] PDF [ref_arm_2128] PDF [ref_arm_2129] PDF [ref_arm_2145] PDF [ref_arm_4630] PDF [ref_arm_5126] PDF [ref_arm_2161] PDF [ref_arm_4267] PDF.
235. Helmet [ref_arm_1778] PDF lacks a medial ridge. I could not examine it, but it is visibly restored and assembled from different helmets; see Karcheski and Richardson (2003), p. 9. Its skull may date to about 1500, with earlier components added. Original skulls of the group probably all had a central ridge; the ridge on this helmet’s forehead reinforcement suggests it originally accompanied such a skull.
236. Berbenni (1973).
237. For further information (in Italian language) see: http://www.comune.bienno.bs.it/Pages/Pagine_Generiche/?Id=48864 (24.01.2012).
238. The source locates Beretta’s headquarters from 1526 onwards in Val Trompia, neighbouring the valley containing Bienno. This geographical and company-history statement is retained as the dissertation’s account.
239. On the armourers of Brescia see: Rossi (1972).
240. This should focus on tracking down depictions of these items in contemporary artworks.
241. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1891), Reg. 8511.
242. July the 6th, Augsburg: The city council of Augsburg answers to a letter of Sigmund Gossenprot und Ludwig Hoser: …and [have found within a sealed letter by the Emperor, containing [… a draft and a pattern of a kettlehat, of which we should order a certain number…, from: Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1891), Reg. 8523, translated by the author.
243. [ref_arm_3653] PDF [ref_arm_3654] PDF [ref_arm_3655] PDF [ref_arm_3656] PDF [ref_arm_3657] PDF [ref_arm_3660] PDF [ref_arm_3661] PDF [ref_arm_3662] PDF [ref_arm_3663] PDF [ref_arm_3664] PDF [ref_arm_3665] PDF [ref_arm_3666] PDF [ref_arm_3667] PDF [ref_arm_3699] PDF.
244. Wackernagel (1982a), p. 80, fig. 16, illustrates a teaching display on breastplate development, including plain examples numbered 1, 3 and 4.
245. After: Wackernagel (1982a), p. 26.
246. [ref_arm_3491] PDF [ref_arm_3492] PDF [ref_arm_3493] PDF [ref_arm_3494] PDF [ref_arm_3495] PDF [ref_arm_3496] PDF [ref_arm_3497] PDF [ref_arm_3501] PDF [ref_arm_3502] PDF [ref_arm_3503] PDF [ref_arm_3504] PDF [ref_arm_3505] PDF [ref_arm_3506] PDF.
247. Treitzsaurwein (1775), p. 98. Translation by the author: “[… furthermore, the wise-king in his armoury developed a marvelous way for the making of combat-armour for his foot soldiers. In his armoury at one time thirty breastplates and also backplates were embossed. Hence, in his armoury in one year a large number of armour was made for the “Landsknechts” fighting on foot. This is how marvelous and artistic this king has been.” The statement is imprecise. Deep-drawing a stack of thirty breastplates in a single blow would not be feasible. The writer may instead have meant that thirty plates were stamped in one day; see the discussion below.
248. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1884), Reg. 738.
249. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1884), Reg. 784.
250. The cannonball smith was probably commissioned because experience of forging shot in dies supplied the relevant skills.
251. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1884), Reg. 816. Translation by the author: “[… two die-anvils with their core and equipment for the making of backplates and arm defenses, so Conrad Seusenhofer, his armourer to the court, would be able to stamp out all the work that he has to finish.”
252. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1883), Reg. 854. Translation by the author: “[… an anvil as a model for armour-plate.“
253. For further explanations on the modern meaning of the word see: http://www.zeno.org/Lueger- 1904/A/Schabotte?hl=schabotte (20.02.2011).
254. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1884), Reg. 1010.
255. Translation by the author (with interpretations of the unclear passages): “Those who make breastplates – one of them makes arm-defenses for the foot soldiers – whenever there is a full week make in the time of his imperial highness except of the hardening and the filing 12 breastplates. For whatever one of them worked on stamped breastplates except of the hardening in his own time he was paid for each breastplate 5 Kreuzer. […]”
256. Egg (1992), p. 317.
257. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1884), Reg. 1028. Translation by the author (with interpretations): [… I have organized those busy with the “rough” work and paid by myself for the making of breast- and backplates as follows: Whenever they have finished their regular work and they have their free time they can make breastplates and no matter how many they make after work I pay them 5 Kr. For each. But now they want to have a little bit more. With this organization a lot of breastplates can be made for his imperial highness at low cost. These rough-workers make on a weekly bill after their regular work – sometimes more, sometimes less – enormous 18 breastplates and 5Kr. for each makes a sum of 1.5 gulden rh.” (60 Kreuzer=1 Gulden rh.).]
258. Translation by the author: „Balthis Vischer who forges the pelvis-protections for the breastplates and who has pinned down the breastplates for stamping. He is not paid weekly but only for what he earns more or less a day. Two persons.”
259. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1884), Reg. 1028. Translation by the author: “[… Furthermore Conz Teininger who I need for several works in the armoury, for the stamping and the hammering of the breastplates and for other work, also grinding. I pay him for expenses and salary 1 Gulden rh. a week.”
260. Egg (1992), p. 318-321.
261. Böhmer and Wiesflecker (1990-1996), Reg. 3422 (http://regesten.regesta- imperii.de/index.php?uri=1495-05-12_3_0_14_1_0_3428_3422).
262. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1884), Reg. 902.
263. See: http://www.nuernberginfos.de/muehlen-nuernberg/sandmuehle.html (23.12.2012).
264. Grancsay (1932), blue etching pp. 345-346, 668; for deep etching see pp. 668-669.
265. Reitzenstein (1959), p.77.
266. See: http://www.lederpedia.de/lederherstellung/gerbung/saemischgerbung (23.12.2012).
267. Not all modern armour was intended to deceive: some served decorative or scholarly purposes. “Reproduction” is therefore used as the general term here.
268. Mowbray (1967), p. 15.
269. Boeheim (2000), pp. 622–640, surveys twenty-one major European armour collections and additional private holdings. First published in 1890, its list was not updated, although many collections subsequently changed or disappeared. Cripps-Day (1925) demonstrates the early demand for a record of private, dealer and auction sales. A continuing comprehensive register remains desirable. The database developed here can attach successive provenance records to each object, helping reconstruct dispersed collections.
270. Reitzenstein (1969) p. 70.
271. Bäumel (2004), Schöbel and Karpinski (1985) and Schöbel and Schaal (1985).
272. A sixteenth-century illustrated inventory appears in Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1889), pp. CCXLII–CCCXXIII, and (1890), pp. CCCLIII–CCCC. Later catalogues include Quintana Lacaci (1987) and Valencia Don Juan (1898).
273. Thomas and Gamber (1976), p.11.
274. Thomas (1981).
275. Thomas and Gamber (1976) pp. 11-12.
276. Luchner (1958).
277. Laking (1903) and Galea and Mintoff (1990).
278. „Zeug“ can be translated as „iron stuff“.
279. For municipal defence organisation and the role of arsenals, see Wackernagel (1982b) and Waissenberger (1977).
280. See: Gamber (1977), p. 40.
281. Vienna’s catalogues provide little detailed provenance. These finer, individually differing objects may have entered later. The 1977 catalogue offers possible origins for only [ref_arm_3744] PDF [ref_arm_1894] PDF, perhaps acquired with other equipment from the wealthy citizen Jörg Strasser’s armoury in 1504: Düriegl (1977), p. 76, no. 49, and p. 84, no. 115.
282. On armour in English churches see: Cripps-Day (1922)
283. Mann (1930) and Mann (1938).
284. See: Museen der Stadt Landshut (2009), p. 145.
285. In his historism castle „Abbotsford“ also Sir Walter Scott had gathered some antique arms and armour.
286. Anstruther (1963), pp. 246-247.
287. For a short note on the Eglinton Tournament see: Watts (1989).
288. Franz I of Erbach-Erbach acquired objects from the Nuremberg, Amberg and Neumarkt arsenals.
289. On the history of the armour coming from Rhodes see: Karcheski and Richardson (2003).
290. On 13 December 2011, Pierre Bergé in Brussels sold part of the Berlin Klingbeil collection, one of Germany’s last major private armour collections.
291. E. g. the Victoria and Albert Museum, The Mittelmoselmuseum Traben-Trabach, The Museo San Lazzaro degli Armeni etc.
292. For example for the Eglinton Tournament of 1839.
293. Schedelmann (1963), p. 100-101.
294. Laking (1920), p. 112.
295. Laking (1920), p. 112-113.
296. Schedelmann (1966), p.15.
297. Laking (1920), p. 120-121.
298. The Ernst Schmidt catalogue, probably first issued around 1910, was reprinted with commentary in Mowbray (1967). Pages 161–168 also reproduce G. Pigeon’s Paris catalogue.
299. Mowbray (1967), p. 7.
300. On one of the images there is to read: „Nachbildungen alter Waffen und Rüstungen aus Stahl u. Schmiedearbeit in alter Behandlung” (Engl.: Replicas of old arms and armour made of steel and smithery in old treatment. Transl. by author) Mowbray (1967), pl. 2, p. 19. The meaning of the sentence is not absolutely clear. The word “Stahl” or “steel” is often used for any kind of material which does not have to be carbon steel suitable for heat treatment. It also remains unclear if “alte Behandlung” or “old treatment” refers only to the smithery or also to the production of the material.
301. See: Mowbray (1967), p. 8-9.
302. Grancsay’s introduction to the Schmidt reprint identifies several sixteenth-century-style reproductions in private collections: Mowbray (1967), pp. 10–11.
303. Gimbel (1904)
304. Mowbray (1967), p. 101, pl. 61. The source note states that the suit’s or its components’ whereabouts are unclear; this conflicts with the location proposed in the main text.
305. See: Mowbray (1967), p. 75, pl. 36.
306. Schedelmann (1963), p. 100-101.
307. Schedelmann reproduces an image of Hugel at work, see: Schedelmann (1964a), p. 51.
308. Hayward (1977), p. 78.
309. Laking (1920), p. 113-116.
310. Watts (1992).
311. Schedelmann (1948).
312. Kroener (1988), p. 98.
313. Schedelmann (1964b), p. 116-117.
314. For the discussion of an electro plated armour-piece see chapter [An electro-plated helmet in Delft].
315. For a comprehensive overview see: Meißner and Doktor (2001).
316. V olger (1873), p. 366.
317. Watts (1992), p. 101.
318. See for example: Potier Echelles (1901), p. 10.
319. Boeheim (2000), p. 584.
320. Edge and Williams (2001), p. 235, 239.
321. Grancsay (1952-53).
322. Müller (1999).
323. E. g. Charles Alexander Baron de Cosson, James Gow Mann, Francis Henry Cripps-Day and Sir Guy Francis Laking.
324. Boeheim (2000), p. 572-581.
325. Unfortunately no company names are quoted.
326. Mowbray (1967), p. 13.
327. Compare: Potier Echelles (1901), p. 28-29.
328. See chapter [The making of rivets].
329. Potier Echelles (1901), p. 13-15.
330. Boeheim (1897-99).
331. Potier Echelles (1918-20), p. 298-299.
332. With what else should the plate have been cut?
333. Grancsay (1932).
334. The comparable display known at the time was the Eglinton equipment in Leeds’s Tournament Galleries. During my research visit in spring 2010, those rooms were closed for refurbishment, preventing examination.
335. Grancsay (1932), p. 47.
336. Grancsay’s emphasis on archaeology overlooks art history, another discipline traditionally concerned with authenticity.
337. Grancsay (1932), p. 47.
338. Schedelmann (1963), (1964a), (1964b), (1965), (1966).
339. Schedelmann (1963).
340. V erhoeven (2007).
341. Piersig (1988).
342. Overman (1851).
343. Charles (1998), p. 497. [Editorial note: the source note begins with the incomplete words “This layered”; their intended connection to the main text requires clarification.]
344. Anonymous (1880), p. 79.
345. For a closer description of the development of the Thomas-Process see: Piersig (1989).
346. Lang et al. (1988), p. 390.
347. Alloy: metallic substance composed of two or more elements, as either a compound or a solution. The components of alloys are ordinarily themselves metals, though carbon, a nonmetal, is an essential constituent of steel, see: Anonymous. Definition of "alloy", Encyclopedia Britannica.
348. Agricola (1977).
349. Johannsen (1925).
350. Mutz (1981), Gut (1986), on the late 19th century techniques for rolling iron plates see: Anonymous (1987).
351. Anonymous (1983).
352. Mutz (1983).
353. Koch et al. (1939), Reg. 5820. (http://regesten.regesta-imperii.de/index.php?uri=1409-05- 27_1_0_10_0_0_5827_5820).
354. Karsten (1816) pp. 601 ff.
355. Karsten uses “Schiefern”, related to “Schiefer” (schist), apparently to describe delamination in layered material. The source cites Rimer et al. (2009), entry 1445, 3), as a dictionary reference; that bibliographic identification requires checking.
356. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1895), Reg. 13651.
357. See: Strauch (1986), p.185. Free translation by the author: “Furthermore he has an iron-hat made of steel. No man on earth ever had such a strong hat.”
358. E.g. see: Böhmer and Wiesflecker (1990-1996), Reg. 13436. (http://regesten.regesta- imperii.de/index.php?uri=1499-06-19_4_0_14_3_2_640_13436).
359. “Wälschi” probably means Italian or French. German “welsch” often denotes Romance-speaking European peoples.
360. Panzer could also mean ring-armour, from: Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1899), Reg. 17851.
361. See: Ress (1967), p. 827-829.
362. Böhmer and Wiesflecker (1990-1996), Reg. 11610. (http://regesten.regesta- imperii.de/index.php?uri=1501-03-02_1_0_14_3_1_2642_11610).
363. Exceptions include the entirely copper-alloy hand-defence pair [ref_arm_1263] PDF [ref_arm_1303] PDF and helmet [ref_arm_1414] PDF. Each of [ref_arm_1060] PDF [ref_arm_1079] PDF has a copper-alloy metacarpal lame. Copper-alloy finger-root plates occur on pairs [ref_arm_1059] PDF [ref_arm_1124] PDF, [ref_arm_1074] PDF [ref_arm_1125] PDF, [ref_arm_1142] PDF [ref_arm_1096] PDF, [ref_arm_1208] PDF [ref_arm_1246] PDF, [ref_arm_1207] PDF [ref_arm_1244] PDF, [ref_arm_1245] PDF [ref_arm_1272] PDF, [ref_arm_1209] PDF [ref_arm_1247] PDF, and individual objects [ref_arm_1063] PDF [ref_arm_1066] PDF [ref_arm_1071] PDF [ref_arm_1250] PDF [ref_arm_1129] PDF [ref_arm_4904] PDF. Reproductions with such plates include [ref_arm_1045] PDF [ref_arm_1109] PDF and my Freiburg reconstruction [ref_arm_5111] PDF. The original repeats [ref_arm_1096] PDF in its list.
364. In 1496 Maximilian ordered payment to a locksmith for an iron and sheet-metal chest in his private chamber: Böhmer and Wiesflecker (1990–1996), Reg. 7659, http://regesten.regesta-imperii.de/index.php?uri=1496-11-25_2_0_14_2_0_4009_7659.
365. This is the analysis of the crystal micro-structure of iron and the testing of its hardness.
366. Williams (2003).
367. For further and more detailed explanations on the heat-treating of steel see: Verhoeven (2007).
368. Brepohl (1987), p. 59.
369. Bartl (2005), p. 663-664.
370. V erhoeven (2007), p. 65.
371. The summary on diffusion is extracted from p. 63-70 in V erhoeven (2007).
372. Bartl (2005), p. 664-665.
373. Williams (2003), p. 731 and here chapter [A type-II helmet in the Royal Armouries].
374. Here “metallurgy” encompasses the examination methods discussed, including metallography and hardness testing.
375. For preceding studies on armour usually the unit VPH was used.
376. Craddock (2009), p. 154-156.
377. For more precise measurements, an argon atmosphere and tungsten electrode may be used. Instrument chambers are often too small for whole armour objects, requiring a detached sample.
378. Buchwald and Wivel (1998); Pigott (1989); Rose et al. (1990); Williams (1991).
379. According to: Sperl (2001), p. 8, up to 1 cm3 of sample material would be necessary.
380. Cook et al. (2003), p. 22.
381. For a substantial study of radiocarbon dating of iron and its limitations, see Cook et al. (2003).
382. For sword examination, see Wessel (1995), cited twice in the source. For archaeological applications of micro-CT, see Kastner et al. (2007).
383. For easy-to-understand explanations on the basics of computed-tomography see: Avinash C. Kak (2001).
384. See: Charles (1998), p. 500.
385. See: Charles (1998), p. 498.
386. Espelund (1996), p. 53.
387. Köstler (2006), p. 137.
388. Anonymous (1880), p. 87.
389. See: Anonymous (1880), p. 80, tab.
390. E. g. Anonymous (1880), p. 87.
391. Oppermann (1863), here p. 433-435.
392. Overman (1851), p. 365-366.
393. Smith (2004).
394. Five positions along a 100 mm line across the cuff yielded 225–363 HV: Goll (2009), p. 87.
395. See: Williams (2003), p. 898-902.
396. Edge and Williams (2001), p. 239, exclude a previously associated “tilting socket” from Wallace suit A21 because its metallurgy differed from the other components.
397. Williams (1979).
398. Starley (2004).
399. This person is now the curator of arms and armour in a famous south western Swiss historical museum.
400. Bauer and Demmler (1941).
401. Both monumental brasses in Römhild’s town church were made during the sitters’ lifetimes: Bauer and Demmler (1941), pp. 2–3.
402. Gyngell (1959).
403. E. g. Boeheim (2000), p. 633-680; Nickel (1974), p. 281-311.
404. E. g. Thomas and Gamber (1976); Di Carpegna (1969).
405. For more on the similarities of master-marks on products of different craft-branches see: Goll and Sensfelder (2011).
406. Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sammlungen in Wien (1900), Reg. 18351. The document does not identify which Freiburg is meant. Breisgau and Üechtland are proposed because other namesakes were then small. The source notes specialist crafts in fifteenth-century Fribourg and calls it a “freie Reichsstadt” from 1477; that political description requires verification. Archival research may clarify armour production in either town.
407. Terjanian (2001).
408. A segmented-armour fragment from Otepää Castle, destroyed in 1396, bears a cross within a ring. It may be an exceptionally early armour mark, but the fragment’s inner and outer sides are uncertain: Rachewiltz (2004), p. 108, pl. 3.
409. See chapter [New recognitions on marks].
410. Many later items in the collection also bear this seal mark.
411. Wackernagel describes several monk-head marks on arms and armour. His new Landwehr-period variant probably refers to the lead seal: Wackernagel (1982a), pp. 28, 187–188.
412. Time constraints prevented systematic checking of later armour for these seals during the storage visit.
413. Wackernagel (1982a), p. 30 + 37.
414. For more details on the “Landwehr” see: http://www.bayern-buergerwehr.de/Geschichtliches.html.
415. Braun published the first partly illustrated catalogue of the Zeughaus: Braun (1866).
416. Wackernagel (1982a), p. 38.
417. In November 2012, I informed Munich Stadtmuseum staff that this helmet belonged to the Zeughaus inventory.
418. I helped identify [ref_arm_1749] PDF, previously considered a wartime loss, and other objects as former Zeughaus holdings.
419. See for example: Reitzenstein (1964), p. 19.
420. Schedelmann (1964a), p. 52-53, fig. 1.
421. The book got lost in World War II.
422. Gamber (1957).
423. Gamber (1977), p. 39.
424. Thomas and Gamber (1976), p. 100.
425. Published by: Richardson (1954), p. 6-7; Gamber (1957), p. 43, 48 and Levkoff and Hearst (2008), p. 20-21.
426. It was bought by the DIA in 1953, see Levkoff and Hearst (2008), p. 20.
427. A November 1950 examination report, written while the suit remained with Hearst, already records these assessments. It also calls the backplate’s pelvis lames replacements: "Backplate authentic, except extension plates at sides and three garde-rein lames (which are apparently old metal, but restorations)". The report does not explain the certainty of this judgement, despite recognising old metal and workmanship consistent with the plate.
428. See: Levkoff and Hearst (2008), p. 21
429. Most of the items of this collection are now part of the collections in the Marksburg (Braubach, Germany).
430. Galerie Fischer (1964), lot 199.
431. Laking (1920), p. 119, fig. 1532.
432. Laking (1920), p. 119.
433. Schedelmann (1964a), p. 52-53, fig. 1.
434. Data taken from the museum-register.
435. See chapters [Type-VII] and [Reproduced ornaments on genuine armour].
436. See the discussion in: Watts (1992), p. 102.
437. The closest comparisons likewise have pointed visors and separately made skulls. Other Type VIII forms generally combine the skull, nape and rear shoulder protection in one plate.
438. Possibly also [ref_arm_1658] PDF, but its unknown location and poor frontal photograph prevent secure classification.
439. Watts (1992), p. 104.
440. Spalding (1981).
441. It was not possible to examine the Leeds head piece and no measurements for comparisons are published yet.
442. Watts (1992), p. 104.
443. Williams (1981).
444. Williams (1981), p. 81-82.
445. Williams (2003), p. 731.
446. See chapter [The making of plates].
447. Spalding (1981), p. 8.
448. See also chapter [Notes on the history of armour reproduction and restoration].
449. Puype (2003).
450. V olger (1873), p. 366.
451. Pierre Bergé & associés (2011), lot nr. 182.
452. Galerie Fischer (1934).
453. The catalogue omits an interior photograph and gives only a comparison in the scarce 1934 sale catalogue. Readers therefore cannot readily compare the marks or assess the attribution independently.
454. The source relies on the HJRK’s inherited Habsburg holdings and an asserted absence of private acquisitions to support authenticity. This is a collection-history argument, not a substitute for object-specific provenance verification.
455. For the basics of this method see: Helfen et al. (2005) and Helfen et al.
456. I thank Lukas Helfen, Elias Hamann, Angelica Cecilia and Daniel Hänschke for generously examining the samples and helping interpret the images.
457. I thank Robert Weis of Hermann Historica, Munich, for donating the object for examination.
458. In these reconstructions, higher-density regions appear brighter and lower-density voxels darker.
459. It was generously provided by the “Real Wrought-iron Company”, Lyndhurst.
460. I thank Achim Wirtz for donating numerous samples and helping me understand manual iron refining.
461. This concern arises from a case involving a rare fifteenth-century breastplate in a Berlin museum. Samples were removed from an internal delamination, but no report was published. A personal email described the conclusion: “We tested the Berlin […] brust quite some time ago and it proved to be modern metal, the sort of thing car-bodies are made out of.” I subsequently examined the object and located the sampling damage; my earlier photographs documented its prior condition. Museum staff informed me that the removal had not been authorised. In my assessment, examining an isolated layer while overlooking the visible delamination did not justify the conclusion. This account rests on personal examination and correspondence, not a published analytical report.
462. Possible comparisons include laminography, metallography and X-ray diffraction. During method development, destructive analysis of the same experimental samples may be necessary to validate non-destructive results.
463. Sperl (2001)